Objective: In the anterior region, the resorption of the buccal plate of bone after tooth extraction leads to contraction of the overlying soft tissues, resulting in an esthetic problem. In the socket shield technique, the buccal root section of the tooth is maintained, to preserve the buccal bone for immediate implant placement. The aim of this randomized clinical trial was to investigate the effect of leaving a gap or not between implant and retained root fragment on bone dimensions and soft tissue esthetics.
Methods: This was a 2 armed parallel group randomized clinical trial with allocation ratio 1:1. Patients were eligible in case they needed immediate implant replacing teeth in esthetic zone with sufficient buccal bone support. CBCT was performed immediately after the intervention and 12 months later.
Results: Forty six patients (26 females & 20 males) were enrolled in the study with 23 of them placed in contact with shield and 23 were placed palatal leaving a gap to graft with a xenograft. After 12 months, excellent soft tissue stability was reported (mean pink esthetic score at placement group A: 12.00±1.60 after 12 months 12.90±1.69, group B 12.62±2.07 and after 12 months 12.38±2.20) Using both surgical techniques. Radiographic crestal bone level changes mean for group A was -0.26±0.52 and for group B -0.34±0.31. There was a strong positive correlation between clinical and radiographic bone width values which was statistically significant (r=0.782, p<0.001). Width and thickness of keratinized gingiva showed no significant difference between values measured in both groups. Non-significant difference between studied groups according to the labial plate of bone clinical and radiographic changes after immediate implantation.
Conclusion: Within the limitations of this study, the present data seem to support that the clinical outcome of the socket shield technique with immediate implant placement placed in contact or leaving a gap gave excellent esthetic results.
Keywords:
Extraction socket, immediate implants, immediate loading, immediate temporization, socket shield